Mickey & Bill's Pizza Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Mickey & Bill's Pizza, the local gem nestled in Indianapolis that promises to satisfy your cravings with its diverse menu. Here, you'll find a delightful selection of sandwiches, salads, and irresistible snacks that cater to all tastes.

  • Sandwiches: Treat yourself to the Baked Ham & Cheese or the savory Pizza Sub, all priced at just $6.95, each offering a burst of flavors.
  • Snacks: Savor the Jo Jo Potatoes or indulging Garlic Knots for a tasty start.
  • Salads: Fresh options like the Fajita Chicken Salad and classic Toss Salad round out the menu, perfect for a light meal.

Customers rave about the hearty portions and expertly cooked dishes, especially the renowned Mars Hill Monster Pizza. With a warm, welcoming vibe, Mickey & Bill's is where quality and comfort meet—making it a go-to for pizza lovers in the area.

Snacks Appetizers

Breadsticks

pick cheese, pizza sauce, or garlic butter to dip them.

$2.55

Mozzarella Breadsticks

breadstick brushed with garlic butter then topped with mozzarella cheese, sprinkled with oregano, then baked.

$4.49

Breadsticks & Meat

after the mozarella goes on, we cover them with crumbled sausage or pepperoni.

$5.49

Garlic Knots

a new york favorite. strips of pizza dough tied into a knot, and drenched in garlic butter.

$2.29

Garlic Bread

$2.29

Jo Jo Potatoes

a quartered idaho breaded then broasted.

$2.99

Toss Salad

lettuce, carrots, red cabbage and tomatoes.

$3.29

Chef Salad

our tossed salad topped with our own baked ham and blended taco cheese.

$4.95

Mickey & Bill's Italian Salad

our tossed salad topped with black olives, banana peppers, pepperoni and cheese.

$4.95

Fajita Chicken Salad

our tossed salad topped with fajita chicken strips, black olives, banana peppers, onions, and cheese.

$4.95

Salads

Sandwiches

Baked Ham & Cheese

one of our favorites! we bake our own ham and top it with mozzarella cheese then bake it.

$6.95

Stromboli

stromboli steak, with pizza sauce, mushrooms, onions & mozzarella cheese.

$6.95

Italian Sub

salami, pepperoni & ham bake with mozzarella then topped with lettuce, tomato, and a little italian dressing.

$6.95

Pizza Sub

italian sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, and pizza sauce topped with mozzarella cheese & baked.

$6.95

Veggie

mushrooms, onions, green pepper, banana peppers, & black olives topped with mozzarella cheese.

$6.95

Bbq Chicken

bbq sauce with fajita chicken, onions, and our mozzarella & provolone cheese.

$6.95

Chicken Ranch

ranch dressing, fajita chicken, bacon, onions, and cheese.

$6.95

The Big Wing

10 wings either plain, hot, or with sweet baby rays bbq sauce with jojos, side, roll & apple butter.

$10.95

The Little Wing

5 wings either plain, hot, or with sweet baby rays bbq sauce with jojos, side, roll & apple butter.

$6.95

Dinner

Broasted Chicken

Chicken Dinners

include a 4 oz. side, jojo potatoes, & roll.

$6.45

Chicken Only

$6.95

Buckets - Chicken Dinners

included a jojo potatos, roll and sides.

$14.95

Buckets - Chicken Only

included a jojo potatos, roll and sides.

$9.95

Chicken By The Piece

$1.49

Jumbo Breaded Wings

big ones! your sauce on the wings or on the side. pick your sauce. we make our own hot sauce and our specialty dip is our own chipolte ranch. you can also choose from the following: sweet baby ray's bbq, frank's red hot sweet heat bbq wing sauce, frank's red hot hot buffalo wing sauce, louisianna hot sauce. we hand bread daily or skip the breading and ask for them naked.

$0.80

Taco

taco meat topped with mozzarella & provolone cheese baked then covered with fresh lettuce, onions, tomatoes, and a blended taco cheese, and served with sour cream & taco sauce.

$7.25

Mars Hill Monster

absolutely everything. it's hefty.

$7.25

All Meat

crumbled sausage & hamburger, bacon, italian sausage, ham, pepperoni, mozzarella & provolone cheese.

$7.25

Veggie

fresh mushrooms, banana peppers, black olives, green pepper, onions & tomatoes topped with mozzarella& provolone cheese.

$7.00

Works

crumbled sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onions, pepperoni, mozzarella & provolone cheese. a 5 topping for the price of 4.

$7.00

Bbq Chicken Pizza

bbq sauce with fajita chicken, banana peppers, onions, and our mozzarella & provolone cheeses.

$7.00

Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Pizza

ranch dressing, fajita chicken, bacon, onions and our mozzarella & provolone cheeses.

$7.00

Specialty Pizzas

Pizza

Cheese

$3.95

1 Topping

$4.70

2 Toppings

$5.45

3 Toppings

$6.25

4 Toppings

$7.00

Additional Toppings

$0.75

Extra Cheese

$0.75

Premium Topping

$0.75

Atkins Old Fashioned Creamy Cheesecake

$3.95

Cookies

our own homemade "from scratch".

$0.99

Desserts